Author: Vinnakota, S;Aoshima, Y
First published: N/A
Standard: £9 + VAT
An IStructE account gives you access to a world of knowledge. Create a profile to receive details of our unique range of resources, events and training.
Added to basket
Vinnakota, S;Aoshima, Y
Dr. E. C. Hambly (M) : I wish to challenge the authors' statement that grillage analysis is inappropriate for decks with less than four cells. I will substantiate this challenge by demonstrating that the shear-flexible grillage can be used to reproduce the structural behaviour of a box-girder deck with the accuracy of a more sophisticated technique. I advocate grillage analysis of cellular decks because-it is an automatic method which does not require a high level of concentration in the design office over a long period, it is relatively inexpensive for analysis of multiple load cases, it can accommodate variations of geometry in plan and section, and it can be used with accuracy. There are shortcomings but they are no worse than those associated with grillage analysis of beam and slab decks. I should add that my enthusiasm for grillage analysis has developed considerably since I changed to the C&CA program which has very simple and clear data praparation and output.
In my circular letter dated 28 February 1974, written on behalf of both the Department of Education and Science and the Department of the Environment, as is this letter, I suggested the precautions which might be taken pending a report from the Building Research Establishment on their investigation into the causes of the failure of precast prestressed high alumina cement concrete roof beams over the swimming pool at the Sir John Cass Foundation and Red Coat School, Stepney. I also undertook to write to you again as soon as further information became available from the Building Research
Establishment. An interim statement is given below.
The author's experience on several codes-of-practice committees has led him to the conclusion that one of the greatest fields of uncertainty lies in the specifying of effective lengths of continuous columns. This is coincidental with the difficulty of calculating elastic critical load factors and dealing with frame instability. Comprehensive design charts are given for effective lengths of columns with any local
degree of end restraint, both for sway and no sway conditions. To design for the limit-state of collapse it is essential to discover new 'desk' methods of dealing with overall frame instability when effective lengths based on local restraints are not accurate enough. A new technique of 'stiffness distribution', akin to moment distribution, will be acceptable in a drawing office, both for steel and reinforced concrete frames, at the same time providing rapid estimates of the other limit-state of permissible sidesway. Important modifications for strain hardening and composite panel stiffening are included, indicating the urgent need for more full-scale tests on composite action with cladding. The emphasis throughout has been on simplicity of theory and of the many worked examples.