Discussion on Active Engineering History by Mr R.J.M. Sutherland
Date published

N/A

First published: N/A

Price

Standard: £9 + VAT
Members/Subscribers: Free

Buy Now

Added to basket

Back to Previous

Discussion on Active Engineering History by Mr R.J.M. Sutherland

The Structural Engineer
Discussion on Active Engineering History by Mr R.J.M. Sutherland
Date published

N/A

First published

N/A

Price

Standard: £9 + VAT
Members/Subscribers: Free

Buy Now

Dr J. G. M. Wood (F) You gave a beautiful example in your reference to the Royal Commission into the failure of a mill building. Students nowadays do not have the benefit of a Royal Commission on the failure of the Milford Haven Bridge; they do have the Australian Royal Commission on the failure of the Yarra Bridge. Do we analyse and recall our failures in public sufficiently well? My view is that, in this country, we grossly fail in this, and there is a classic paper by Alastair Walker, I think written for this Institution, about lessons from failures of Victorian structures, which he used to illustrate what was going wrong in the area of box girders. He could not mention modern steel bridges - someone might have sued him! - but history enabled him to draw the lessons from the past without pointing the finger. The key question is this: do we, as an Institution or a society, properly wash our linen in public so that it is on the record? The Milford Haven collapse is not on the record.

Additional information

Format:
PDF
Publisher:
The Institution of Structural Engineers

Tags

Opinion Issue 13

Related Resources & Events

The Structural Engineer
Academia. Civil and Structural Engineering at Bolton Institute

Academia. Civil and Structural Engineering at Bolton Institute

The first full-time engineering course at Bolton started in 1958. By the early 1960s the beginnings of the present School had received full recognition of its comes by the then Council of Engineering Institutions. The School now has 34 academic staff, 18 support staff and over 950 full and part-time students, working within an Institute which has the mission ‘to be widely recognised for the accessibility and responsive ness of its services and for its commitment to high quality teaching, learning and research’. Professor C. Melbourne

Price - £9
The Structural Engineer
Sutherland History Lecture. Active Engineering History

Sutherland History Lecture. Active Engineering History

This lecture series, previously named the Star History series, derives from an initiative by Keith White when he was President. He felt that at least some of the activities of the Institution’s History Study Group should reach an audience wider than the Group’s membership. It is perhaps even more appropriate this year to remember who suggested the Study Group. This was Dr George Geddes when he was President in 1971-2. Sadly, George Geddes died last November. Although the History Study Group may seem a small item among his many considerable achievements, I think it is fitting to remember him this evening. Effectively, this lecture series is his ‘grandchild'. R.J.M. Sutherland

Price - £9
The Structural Engineer
Correspondence on Expansion of Concrete due to Alkali-Silica Reaction by D.W. Hobbs

Correspondence on Expansion of Concrete due to Alkali-Silica Reaction by D.W. Hobbs

Mr I.P. Gillson (M) (Central Electricity Generating Board): I draw the attention of specifying engineers to the need to -study carefully the September 1983 draft ‘Guidance notes’ when dealing with particularly vulnerable structures -consider the relevance of tests on mortar prisms and cubes to the risk of ASR damage -consider the scale effects of concrete samples on the risk of ASR damage -examine evidence from concrete that has been damaged by ASR

Price - £9