Report of the Professional Conduct Committee 6 July 2022

Author: Rui Carvalho Pais, Professional Conduct Manager

Date published

17 March 2023

Back to Previous

Report of the Professional Conduct Committee 6 July 2022

Report

Author

Rui Carvalho Pais, Professional Conduct Manager

Date published

17 March 2023

Author

Rui Carvalho Pais, Professional Conduct Manager

In accordance with Procedural Rule 2.25 (01/19/V3REG4PROPCC) the following decision of the Professional Conduct Committee (PCC) is published without the Member's name.

A complaint was made to the Institution arising out of the appointment of a member to determine the structural integrity of a barn. Taking all matters into account the PCC found that the member failed to discharge their duties with care, courtesy, impartiality and fidelity; failed to document the structure of his organisation; failed to engage in detailed discussion of how the clients’ requirements would be met, and failed to supply a letter of engagement or acceptance; failed to take all reasonable steps to ensure that the client understood the scope of the service to be provided including any limitations; failed to supply terms of appointment before any work commenced; failed to ensure that the brief and terms of payment were agreed by the client; and failed to obtain written acceptance prior to commencement of work
 
The PCC, taking into consideration its findings above, decided that the member failed to comply with Articles 1, 5 and 6 of the Code of Conduct.
 
The PCC issued Guidance to the member pursuant to Regulation 4.2.2.1(1) in the following terms:
Members should take all reasonable steps to understand and define the brief with the client, taking all reasonable steps to ensure that their client understands the scope of the service to be provided including any limitations. The terms of appointment should be agreed (preferably in writing) before any work is commenced.
 
The PCC issued Training Orders to the member pursuant to Regulation 4.2.2.1(3) in the specific area of:

  1. Dealing with domestic clients, in particular client communications and producing clear and unambiguous terms of appointment.

  2. Understanding company structure and the lawful basis for VAT registration

 The PCC directed the member to provide an Undertaking pursuant to Regulation 4.2.2.1(4) in the following terms:
I, <member>, undertake to amend the misleading presentation of my practice, to present clearly and unambiguously in all business communications and collateral that I operate as a Sole Practitioner.
 
The PCC issued a Warning to the member pursuant to Regulation 4.2.2.1(5) in the following terms:
The member’s professional conduct as a Chartered Member of the Institution has resulted in a decision by the PCC that there has been a failure by him to comply with Articles 1, 5 and 6 of the Code of Conduct and that any complaint against him which comes before the PCC in the future, resulting from conduct similar to that which gave rise to this complaint, may be dealt with more severely.

Other PCC and Disciplinary Board reports
Report

Report of the Disciplinary Board 15 November 2022

Report of the Disciplinary Board 15 November 2022

The Board considered matters in respect of the issue of a report on a listed building by a member of the Institution, whereby an electronic signature was inserted which purported to be that of an accredited engineer but in fact was inserted without the knowledge...
Date – 17 March 2023
Report

Report of the Professional Conduct Committee 22 February 2023

Report of the Professional Conduct Committee 22 February 2023

The PCC found that a member failed issue an Apology to the complainant, as required of the member by a previous PCC Decision.
Date – 17 March 2023

Related Resources & Events

Regional
Promotional flyer for a 2027 Concept Design Course by The Institution of Structural Engineers, featuring event details and a QR code.

Concept design course 2027: chartered membership exam preparation

Concept design course 2027: chartered membership exam preparation

A 10-week evening course building the concept design skills needed for the Chartered Membership exam.
Date – 28 January 2027
Location – Ramboll, Cornerblock, 2 Cornwall Street Birmingham, B3 2DX
Price – £300
Regional Group
Structural Awards 2024 gala event attendees are photographed whilst posing in front of the camera

Grab-a-Grad Event at University College London

Grab-a-Grad Event at University College London

Ready to take the next step in your career and grow your professional network? Join us at our Grab-a-Grad event for an evening of networking, inspiring conversations and meaningful connections with structural engineers shaping the world around us. It’s a great opportunity to meet industry professionals, exchange ideas, gain insights into different career paths and build valuable connections in a relaxed and welcoming atmosphere. And what’s networking without a few refreshments? Enjoy some light bites and drinks while making new connections! We look forward to welcoming you for an evening of conversation, inspiration and opportunities. We hope to see you there!
Date – 24 November 2026
Location – University College London
Price – Free
Regional Group
Students in lecture hall

Completing the path to Qualification – Advice for candidates and supporters

Completing the path to Qualification – Advice for candidates and supporters

Getting the best preparation for your IPD Submission.
Date – 26 November 2026
Location – The Institution of Structural Engineers
Price – Free