Back to Previous

Addressing the Climate Emergency within a small engineering practice

In this blog, Matt Byatt FIStructE and Vice President, describe his SME's experience in addressing the Climate Emergency.

Having formed in 2019, Subteno are a young but growing engineering practice, and now comprise a team of seven engineers and CAD modellers.  We signed up to the UK Structural Engineers Declare Climate and Biodiversity Emergency following a powerful presentation on the effect that the built environment has on climate change, delivered at an Institution of Structural Engineers Council Meeting in 2018.

Having signed up to the Declaration, we realised how little knowledge we had regarding embodied carbon within materials and construction activities. We did not even know how to measure the carbon within our designs and, to be blunt, had never really given it much thought. We had always been passionate about designing cost and material efficient solutions that were simple to construct. However, embodied carbon now brought another metric into our considerations.  
At the time of signing the Declaration, we shared with our team what we had committed to, and how we wanted to ensure that Subteno was a responsible company, being fully accountable for our carbon footprint.

We started to accumulate knowledge and useful data, but it wasn’t until the launch of the Institution’s Carbon Counting Tool, and the excellent guidance within The Structural Engineer journal, that we felt confident and empowered to make a real step change.

We now include carbon counting in our default setting for every new project, in the same way as we have with CDM (Construction Design and Management Regulations 2015) responsibilities.

After a slow start, we are now actively measuring and counting our embodied carbon and continuously looking at ways to reduce it. We typically add a boxed note onto our drawings stating the level of embodied carbon. In doing so have received feedback that some of our clients are now noting this figure and becoming more aware themselves of the magnitude of embodied carbon within construction. However, we are yet to see any real change in client activities and priorities as a result.

We have also had some minor setbacks. One example is where we specified the lowest grade of concrete (by cement content) that we could on a sub-structure project, to suit the site conditions and design requirements.  Having proudly ‘patted ourselves on the back’ for saving several tonnes of embodied carbon, we later discovered that the contractor had ordered ‘the concrete he normally uses’ assuming that as it was stronger it would be okay. We only found this out from reviewing the concrete certificates and cube test results!

We are finding it relatively easy to have open discussions with our clients regarding the climate and environmental implication of construction and can discuss design options for reducing embodied carbon.  However, to date, the climate emergency has clearly been a lower priority for our clients, who are still driven primarily by financial costs and construction timescales. It may take government carbon taxation before this truly changes.

We are still at an early stage in our journey and realise that there is still much to do. We need to continue to capture more data in order to really start to benchmark our designs and we still need to make carbon awareness second nature. However, we are at least moving in the right direction: we are learning, we are aware, and we are changing.

Related Resources & Events

Report
<h4>Climate Emergency Task Group: End of year report 2020</h4>

Climate Emergency Task Group: End of year report 2020

The Climate Emergency Task Group help the profession to tackle climate breakdown. Their 2020 report reviews the group’s activities through the year.

Date ‐ 17 December 2020
The Structural Engineer
<h4>Setting carbon targets: an introduction to the proposed SCORS rating scheme</h4>

Setting carbon targets: an introduction to the proposed SCORS rating scheme

Will Arnold, Mike Cook, Duncan Cox, Orlando Gibbons and John Orr present SCORS – a proposed carbon rating scheme for structures – and encourage engineers to adopt carbon targets for their projects.

Date ‐ 16 October 2020
Author ‐ Will Arnold, Mike Cook, Duncan Cox, Orlando Gibbons and John Orr
Price ‐ £0
The Structural Engineer
<h4>The Nucleus at Haysfield Girls' School, Bath: achieving low embodied carbon using renewable material</h4>

The Nucleus at Haysfield Girls' School, Bath: achieving low embodied carbon using renewable material

Authors from Integral Engineering Design describe how they met their client's brief for a new science department that would demonstrate sustainable building structures to students. The result - The Nucleus - is a carbon-negative structure which will offset its operational emissions for seven years.

Date ‐ 1 October 2014
Author ‐ Ralph Pelly and Tim Mander (Integral Engineering Design)
Price ‐ £9
The Structural Engineer
<h4>Nature's invention: The Enterprise Centre, University of East Anglia</h4>

Nature's invention: The Enterprise Centre, University of East Anglia

The article showcases the University of East Anglia's Enterprise Centre project, a low-carbon, sustainable building which achieves both Passivhaus standard and BREEAM Outstanding rating.

Date ‐ 4 May 2021
Author ‐ Malachy McNamara
Price ‐ £9
The Structural Engineer
Pie chart showing carbon breakdown of project

We signed the climate declaration - now what? Lessons from counting carbon

Ben Gholam of Price & Myers shares his practice's experience of setting up a carbon-calculation tool and encourages other firms to take the plunge.

Date ‐ 1 July 2020
Author ‐ Ben Gholam
Price ‐ £0
The Structural Engineer
<h4>A brief guide to calculating embodied carbon</h4>

A brief guide to calculating embodied carbon

John Orr, Orlando Gibbons and Will Arnold preview a forthcoming new guide from the Institution on calculating embodied carbon.

Date ‐ 1 July 2020
Author ‐ John Orr, Orlando Gibbons and Will Arnold
Price ‐ £0
Guidance
Blue abstract blocks

Reduced reinforcement through reduced material partial factors

Appendix A of Eurocode 2 permits a reduction in material partial factors for reinforcing steel and concrete. Designing elements with the reduced material partial factors reduces the amount of reinforcement steel required, hence a reduction in embodied carbon and energy, without any loss of performance.

Date ‐ 23 June 2020
Author ‐ Sustainability Panel
Price ‐ Free
Guidance
Blue abstract blocks

Timber and sustainability

This article discusses timbers and carbon, availability and end-of-life issues.

Date ‐ 18 June 2020
Author ‐ Sustainability Panel
Price ‐ Free
Guidance
steel roof

Making your steel specification more sustainable

In the form of embodied carbon, steel is a significant contributor to the climate crisis. This guidance sets out how structural engineers can use their steel specifications to help move the industry towards net zero.

Date ‐ 30 March 2021
The Structural Engineer
<h4>Structural engineering innovation for a zero-carbon world: an R&D agenda to match the carbon budget</h4>

Structural engineering innovation for a zero-carbon world: an R&D agenda to match the carbon budget

Pete Winslow, Mike Sefton and Will Arnold set out a vision for a net-zero structural engineering sector and the R&D that we as a profession need to tackle to get there.

Date ‐ 31 March 2021
Author ‐ Pete Winslow, Mike Sefton and Will Arnold
Price ‐ £0
The Structural Engineer
<h4>Developing a low-carbon, circular economy for steel</h4>

Developing a low-carbon, circular economy for steel

Walter Swann explains how structural engineers can support a transition to a low-carbon steel industry through their design and specifying decisions.

Date ‐ 31 March 2021
Author ‐ Walter Swann
Price ‐ £0
The Structural Engineer
<h4>An introduction to The Structural Carbon Tool</h4>

An introduction to The Structural Carbon Tool

Penny Gowler and Will Arnold preview a new embodied carbon tool that has been developed by Elliott Wood and the Institution of Structural Engineers.

Date ‐ 31 March 2021
Author ‐ Penny Gowler and Will Arnold
Price ‐ £0
The Structural Engineer
Steel beam, timber plank, masonry brick, concrete block

Making low-carbon material choices

Will Arnold, Jenny Burridge, David Moore, Keerthi Ranasinghe and Sean Wilkins argue that engineers should always look to specify the most suitable material for a particular project, and offer advice on how to use materials efficiently once a choice is made.

Date ‐ 1 February 2021
Author ‐ Will Arnold, Jenny Burridge, David Moore, Keerthi Ranasinghe and Sean Wilkins
Price ‐ £0
The Structural Engineer
<h4>How can we reduce the embodied carbon of structural concrete?</h4>

How can we reduce the embodied carbon of structural concrete?

Paul Astle explores potential ways in which engineers can seek reductions in the embodied carbon of structural concrete.

Date ‐ 1 February 2021
Author ‐ Paul Astle
Price ‐ £0
Blog
Blue abstract blocks

11 recommended reads on using timber and bamboo

James Norman and David Trujillo share their favourite guidance documents on timber and bamboo.

Date ‐ 15 January 2021